Muzak for the Classroom?

Muzak for the Classroom?

By: David Kluge

An hour and a half into the movie Pretty Woman, the wealthy Edward Lewis has taken lady-of-the-night Vivian to a Verdi opera. She very demonstrably becomes emotionally involved in the story. It’s a very memorable scene. After the opera, an elderly woman talks to Vivian:

Old Lady at Opera: Did you enjoy the opera, dear?

Vivian: Oh, it was so good, I almost peed my pants!

Old Lady at Opera: What?

Edward Lewis: She said she liked it better than Pirates of Penzance.

Considering the clever rhyme and the incongruity of the gala scene and the language, and considering that I also like The Pirates of Penzance and La Traviata operas, I relish this scene. It also demonstrates the power of music to communicate without specific knowledge of the language of the song. This separation of music and language can also be seen in the so-called “Mel Tillis” effect. Mel Tillis was a well-known American country singer who stuttered, but not when he sang. There definitely is something that indicates communication can occur without using the usual parts of the brain responsible for language—a fact that might be taken advantage of when teaching language using music in Performance in Education.

A black and white illustration of an old record player.

Where does Muzak fit into the classroom?

Muzak, often called elevator-music or doctor’s office music, is usually thought to be a modern phenomenon, but the concept of it was developed in 1920. Inventor/scientist/military general George Owen Squier invented the system and received patents for it throughout the 1920s. The original system sent music over electric lines, and clients were charged on their electric bill. In 1934, Squier, impressed with the made-up brand name “Kodak” for the camera company, decided to make up his own company name by mashing “music” and “Kodak” together and created “Muzak.” From the beginning, Muzak was used to manipulate factory workers’ moods by playing music in 15-minute blocks. The blocks of music became progressively faster and used more brass to encourage workers to speed up their work. Research by the military had shown that this system worked very well, and later research conducted by university professors discovered more sophisticated means to encourage shoppers to spend their money quickly and leave the shop or linger in high-quality expensive shops and develop a mood to buy more expensive items. Muzak used the research to develop music genres that could target particular clientele for different markets. This marriage of music, psychological research, and commerce became a staple for modern capitalistic companies to encourage workers to work harder and faster and to nudge shoppers to behave in ways the client companies desired of them (Jones, S. & Schumacher, T., 1992; North, A., Sheridan, L., & Areni, C., 2015).

BUT, the basic principles of Muzak’s commercial success can also be used by educators to affect students’ moods. When students need to be “woken up,” for example, in the first period of the day, coming towards lunchtime, right after lunch, and towards the end of the day, appropriately motivating music can be used to awaken them. Conversely, when students need to quiet down and concentrate on the task at hand, soothing, calming music can be used. This is the basis for educators’ Muzak described in this article.

A black and white illustration of a tambourine.

Ways I use music in the classroom

I have used music for my classes ever since I started to teach English in Japan in 1983 and was interviewed in 1984 for an article on how I use music by The Japan Times student edition of the newspaper, The Student Times. I became inspired when I realized how effective music was in restaurants as background music (BGM). Restaurant consultant Giada Pezzini (2017) wrote these five reasons to use music in restaurants:

    1. Music creates the atmosphere
    2. Frequency and volume affect the taste of food
    3. Songs can make waiting more pleasant
    4. Music tempo influences eating rhythms
    5. You can induce spending by using the right beat

One of my favorite restaurants, Bronco Billy Steak Restaurant, plays some of my favorite 50s and 60s music and is one of the reasons I like going there. I use music in my classes for many of the same reasons Pezzini listed:

    1. Music creates a unique classroom atmosphere
    2. Frequency and volume of music affect the interest the students show in class
    3. Music can make the waiting more bearable for people who finish early as they wait for other groups to finish the task or for the end of the activity time limit
    4. Music tempo influences working rhythms

 I carry my iPod filled with music that I can use in class when I observe that some intervention is necessary. These are the four ways I have come to use music throughout the class:

    1. Affect moods (energizing, relaxing, happiness-inducing)
    2. Non-physical wall
    3. Classroom management
    4. Part of the lesson 

These uses are described below. 

1. Affect moods (energizing, relaxing, happiness-inducing)

I play music at the very beginning of class that gets the students so fired up that they start each class with applause, no matter when the class begins–at first thing in the morning at 9 a.m., before lunch, after lunch, and at the end of the school day. But when it is time to settle down and get to work, I play soothing instrumental music that allows students to quietly work on an assignment. At the very end of class and on special holidays like Halloween and Christmas, and just before vacation, I play music that makes the students happy. This music is always mentioned as a positive thing on class evaluations.

2. Non-physical wall

It is always difficult to be the first person to break the silence of the classroom to start group work, so when it comes to starting the class on group work time, I first start the soothing music so that nobody has to speak in a vacuum. The music serves the same function as music in a restaurant (Pezzini, 2017)–it serves as a wall preventing people from hearing what the people at the next table are saying. It also allows the students to think that the teacher is not listening to them (even though I always listen to students).

3. Classroom management

I use music for classroom management. What does this mean? Certain music serves as a signal to the students of what they need to do. When it is time to start the class, I play class-starting music that indicates the class is starting and activates the students. When it is time for group work, I play soothing instrumental work that not only puts students in a good mood to get down to work, but also lets students know it is group work time. When it is time for the class to wind down, I play the class-ending music that lets students know that it is time for me to give them homework and release the class. Music serves as the signals for students to know what they will have to do next in class.

4. Part of the lesson

I always use music as part of the lesson. The lyrics to a song are samples of poetry on the topic of the unit that I use as texts for the students to read. Every unit includes several song lyrics, and the song is played so that students are enticed to read the lyrics. For example, on a chapter on general disappointment, I introduce the song and lyrics to Kelly Clarkson’s “Stronger” (aka “What Doesn’t Kill You”) and to introduce the unit on disappointment in love I use the song “Crying” sung by the male singer Roy Orbison AND sung by the female singer K. D. Lang so students can see the lyrics interpreted from the male and female perspective. I always use the video that includes the lyrics so students can listen to the music and read the lyrics at the same time. In addition, I use song lyrics as perfect pieces for readers theatre. I say perfect because not only are they the right length (3-4 minutes long), but students can access the YouTube video anytime to check on pronunciation. (For a description of how to do this activity, check my article https://jaltpiesig.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Classroom-Resources-vol-2-FINAL.pdf, pp. 25-33.)

A black and white illustration of a grand piano.

Usual songs I use

To further illustrate my use of music in class, I provide a list of typical songs and their purposes in this section.

Usual songs I use to start classes

Songs that start out slow and ramp up to a rocking song are what I generally use to begin classes:

Songs with a driving beat (to energize students)

Happy songs

Songs without vocals/instrumentals (for group work)

    • Orgel+Zutto Love Time (easy listening album)
    • Science Fiction Movie Sound Tracks Album (Superman, Star Trek Motion Picture Final Theme, Star Wars, Back to the Future, etc.)

Holiday songs

Halloween

Christmas

Last class before vacation

Conclusion

I completely agree with students who say “No music, no life.” I choose music that I like to listen to so that I can enjoy class time and teach an effective class. Feel free to choose your own songs and experiment with your own Muzak teaching playlist.

Videos

The following videos contain strong language that may not be suitable for all audiences. Viewer discretion is advised.

on the history of Muzak (2 F* bombs)

on the history of Muzak (an F* bomb and several crude expressions)

References

David Kluge has been involved in music since junior high school, participating in choir, swing choir, barbershop quartet, orchestra, and musicals, but unfortunately has become somewhat tone deaf in his old age and has had to promise to his daughter to never sing in public.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *